| Field | Detail |
|---|
| Full Name | Susan Margaret Collins |
| Party | Republican |
| First Elected | 1996 |
| Total Raised (2026 cycle) | $10,463,304 |
| FEC ID | S6ME00159 |
| Residence | Bangor, ME |
| Spouse | Thomas Daffron (m. 2012) |
1 Kavanaugh / Abortion Betrayal
The core attack: Collins cast the deciding vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh after he privately assured her he would respect Roe v. Wade as settled precedent. Kavanaugh then voted to overturn Roe in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health (2022). This is the first time Collins faces voters since that ruling.
Finding 1.1: The Kavanaugh Assurance and Betrayal CRITICAL
- What happened
- In October 2018, Collins gave a 45-minute Senate floor speech announcing her vote to confirm Kavanaugh, citing his assurances that Roe was "settled law." In June 2022, Kavanaugh voted with the majority to overturn Roe.
- Collins' response
- Called the decision "inconsistent" with what Kavanaugh told her. Said he "misled" her in private assurances.
- Source tier
- T1 (Senate voting record) + T2 (multi-source: NBC, CNN, Washington Post, WGME)
- Political impact
- This is the single most potent attack line. Maine voters support abortion rights. Democrats have already launched a website targeting Collins on this issue ahead of the Dobbs anniversary.
- NBC News: Collins/Manchin said they were "misled" by Kavanaugh/Gorsuch
- WGME: Collins calls Dobbs "completely inconsistent"
- Maine Democratic Party: launched website targeting Collins over abortion
- The Nation: "Brett Kavanaugh Has Beclowned Susan Collins"
Finding 1.2: Post-Dobbs Voting Pattern HIGH
- What happened
- Despite expressing outrage over Dobbs, Collins voted NOT to confirm a judge with a history of defending abortion rights, further undermining her stated position.
- Source tier
- T1 (voting record) + T2 (Maine Beacon reporting)
- Political impact
- Shows the "misled" narrative may be performative rather than genuine.
2 STOCK Act Violation / Financial Conflicts
Finding 2.1: Violated the Law She Helped Write HIGH
- What happened
- Collins' husband Thomas Daffron purchased $15,001–$50,000 in Pfizer corporate bonds on February 3, 2026. Collins failed to disclose this within the required 45-day window under the STOCK Act — a law she helped write and championed. Disclosure came 5 days late.
- Source tier
- T1 (Senate financial disclosure filings, STOCK Act records)
- Political impact
- "She wrote the law, then broke it." Collins sits on the HELP Committee, which oversees the FDA — the agency that regulates Pfizer. This creates a clear conflict-of-interest narrative.
- Defense
- Third-party advisor failed to notify her in time. The standard fine is $200 and is typically waived for delays under 30 days.
- NOTUS: "Susan Collins Violated a Federal Transparency Law She Helped Write"
- Maine Monitor: detailed reporting on the violation
- Raw Story: "Senate Republican busted violating stock law she helped pass"
Finding 2.2: Husband's Lobbying Career at Jefferson Consulting MODERATE-HIGH
- What happened
- Thomas Daffron was COO of Jefferson Consulting Group (2006-2016), which received nearly $60 million in federal contracts during his tenure. Collins authored contractor reform legislation in 2007 that included provisions appearing to benefit Jefferson's specific service offerings (acquisition workforce training for DHS).
- Source tier
- T2 (Salon, PolitiFact — PolitiFact rated the direct causation claim as "falling short" but confirmed the factual basis of the contracts and legislative overlap)
- Political impact
- "Her husband's firm made $60M from the government while she wrote the rules." PolitiFact's partial debunk actually helps frame this — the facts are real, only the direct causation is disputed.
- Salon: "Susan Collins wrote legislation that made millions for her husband's lobbying firm"
- PolitiFact: Rated claim as partially supported
- HuffPost: "Democrats Take Aim At Susan Collins' Lobbyist Husband"
Finding 2.3: Pfizer Committee Jurisdiction Conflict MODERATE
- What happened
- Collins sits on the Senate HELP Committee (Health, Education, Labor and Pensions), which has jurisdiction over the FDA, CDC, NIH, and SAMHSA. Her husband's purchase of Pfizer bonds creates a direct conflict between her oversight responsibilities and her family's financial interests.
- Source tier
- T1 (committee assignments + financial disclosures)
- Political impact
- Pattern reinforcement — another data point in the conflicts narrative.
3 "Moderate" Brand vs. Trump Loyalty
Finding 3.1: 95% Trump Voting Record CRITICAL
- What happened
- Collins voted with the Trump administration 95% of the time during the current (119th) Congress. Her dissenting votes were largely on nominees (Hegseth, Patel, Bove) who were confirmed anyway — making her "no" votes symbolic rather than consequential.
- Source tier
- T1 (voting record, American Progress Action scorecard)
- Political impact
- Destroys the "moderate" brand. "She votes with Trump 95% of the time, then casts one safe 'no' vote when it doesn't matter to keep her moderate image."
- American Ledger: "Collins Whitewashes Her 94% Voting Record with Trump"
- Maine Democratic Party: "She's Voted With Trump More Than Any Other President"
- Center for American Progress: Trump Scorecard
Finding 3.2: Confirmation Votes for Controversial Trump Nominees HIGH
- What happened
- Collins voted to confirm Linda McMahon (Education Secretary), Russ Vought (OMB), and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (HHS) — all considered controversial appointments. She opposed only Hegseth (Defense) and Patel (FBI).
- Source tier
- T1 (Senate voting record)
- Political impact
- RFK Jr. at HHS is particularly toxic — an anti-vaccine figure overseeing public health during ongoing pandemic concerns.
Finding 3.3: Big Beautiful Bill / Budget Opposition (Late) MODERATE
- What happened
- Collins voted to advance the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" through the process to file amendments, but ultimately voted against it. She also voted against the budget framework and the Rescissions Act.
- Source tier
- T1 (voting record)
- Political impact
- Procedural yes/final no is a known pattern for appearing moderate while enabling passage.
4 Health and Age
Finding 4.1: Essential Tremor Disclosure Under Pressure MODERATE
- What happened
- Collins disclosed on May 6, 2026, that she has had an "essential tremor" for decades, causing trembling in her hands, head, and voice. The disclosure came only after social media scrutiny of her appearance in recent videos. She is 73 years old.
- Source tier
- T1 (direct disclosure to WCSH-TV) + T2 (multi-source: Boston Globe, Washington Post, BDN, Maine Public)
- Political impact
- The health condition itself is benign, but the delayed disclosure pattern — concealing it for decades until forced — reinforces a "lack of transparency" narrative. Combined with the STOCK Act violation, it suggests a pattern of withholding information from voters.
- Defense
- Essential tremor is benign and has not affected her ability to serve. She has maintained a perfect voting attendance record (9,853+ consecutive votes).
5 Lobbying Connections
Finding 5.2: PAC Concentration — 111 PACs, $4M HIGH
- What happened
- Collins received contributions from 111 PACs totaling approximately $4 million (38% of total raised). This is the highest PAC concentration among the ME Senate candidates.
- Source tier
- T1 (FEC Schedule A filings)
- Political impact
- "38 cents of every dollar Collins raises comes from corporate PACs, not Maine voters."
$ Financial Snapshot (FEC T1 Data)
| Metric | Value |
|---|
| Total Raised | $10,463,304 |
| Total Spent | $9,200,000 (est.) |
| Top Donor Type | PACs (38%) |
| Top Expenditure | MENTZER MEDIA SERVICES ($2.7M) |
| Top Individual Donor | Collins Victory Committee ($1.6M) |
| Out-of-State PAC Money | Analysis needed |